Back in my vegetarian days I bought one of the only vegetarian cookbooks readily available — Laurel’s Kitchen — and used it for most meals. My original copy fell apart and I bought “The New Laurel’s Kitchen” when it was published in 1986. I’m not sure what made it “new” but it is bigger than the original.
One of the recipes we still make today, and have memorized, from that book is what the book lists as “Tomato Sauce”. I’ve adapted it a little for our tastes.
We sometimes add half a jar of prepared spaghetti sauce to this recipe to thicken it up if it is thin.
We use this sauce as a topping on pasta and pizza as well as for lasagna and baked tortellini.
- ½ onion, chopped
- 1 clove garlic
- 2 T. olive oil
- 1 small carrot, grated (optional — I rarely include this anymore, but it is for sweetness)
- 2 T. or more chopped sweet red pepper (the original recipe calls for green pepper, but we are not fans of green pepper)
- 1 bay leaf, broken in two bits
- ½ t. oregano, dried or 1 t. fresh (although I usually just use about 1 T. italian spices — from Penzey’s of course — instead of the oregano, thyme and basil)
- ½ t. thyme or 1 T fresh (see note above)
- 1 t. basil or 2 T. fresh, chopped (see note above)
- 2 T. chopped parsley (I rarely have parsley, so don’t use it much — but if you do use it, use flat leaf, Italian parsley instead of the curly kind)
- 2 c tomatoes, coarsely chopped (I usually use a large can of diced tomatoes, but fresh Italian plum is really best)
- 1 t. salt
- freshly ground pepper — a few turns of the grinder will do
- a few shakes of crushed red pepper if you’d like it spicy
Saute onion, sweet red pepper, and garlic clove in oil until onion is soft. Crush garlic with a fork. Add carrot (if desired), bay leaf and herbs. Stir well.
Add tomatoes and seasonings. Simmer 15 minutes or more. Remove bay leaf before serving (or not — we always say that whomever finds the bay leaf is the winner).
This makes about 3 cups of sauce. You can thin it with vegetable broth, but I rarely do. If you don’t like chunks in your sauce, you can process the sauce in a food processor or blender.

